Why Rents in U.S. Suburbs Aren't Falling as Fast as Cities

Once an escape from city prices, suburbs now present a challenging financial landscape for renters.

Why Rents in U.S. Suburbs Aren't Falling as Fast as Cities

For years, renting in the suburbs meant shelling out less than city rents. However, recent data indicates that this traditional disparity is lessening, leading many to wonder why.

From cities to suburbs: The pandemic saw many professionals with remote work opportunities move from city apartments to the suburbs. Driven by factors like high mortgage rates, increased home prices, and urban concerns such as crime, there's been a noticeable preference for extended renting in suburban areas. Consequently, while city rents rose by 20%, suburban rents surged by 27% since March 2020.

Suburban rents outpacing urban growth: Certain suburbs of cities like Atlanta, Detroit, and Seattle experienced rent jumps ranging from 15% to 21%. Over the pandemic's duration, suburban rent growth surpassed city rent growth by approximately 8 percentage points, marking an unprecedented peak. Although suburban rents remain lower on average, the difference has dwindled from 12% in 2019 to just 5.8% in 2022.

The impact of rising home prices: Skyrocketing home prices also play a crucial role in the altered rental landscape. With median home prices exceeding $400,000 and mortgage rates increasing, the typical American finds homeownership less attainable. Consequently, many opt for longer rental durations, reducing the available apartments for newcomers.

Rental construction lags behind demand: Another critical factor is the significant rental unit shortage that predates the pandemic. While the U.S. faced a deficit of approximately 6.8 million affordable rentals in early 2020, construction has since attempted to bridge this gap. Data from 2023 indicates that nearly a million new apartment complexes are underway, aiming to alleviate the shortage over the next couple of years.

➥ THE TAKEAWAY

Why it matters: The traditional gap in rental prices between city centers and suburbs is shrinking. Factors like pandemic-driven migration, soaring home prices, and a shortage of rental units play pivotal roles in this transformation. As new constructions progress, experts anticipate a cooling down of rent hikes, but the changing face of rental economics hints at a more balanced urban-suburban rental landscape in the future.

Source: Why Rents in U.S. Suburbs Aren’t Falling as Fast as Cities

https://www.creconsult.net/market-trends/why-rents-in-u-s-suburbs-arent-falling-as-fast-as-cities/

Grand Prairie 2nd

NEW LISTING: 4,408 SF Medical-Dental | Dallas-Fort Worth Market
eXp Commercial is pleased to present to the market a fully built-out, free-standing 4,408-square-foot medical/dental office building in Grand Prairie, Texas, centrally located 22 miles southwest of downtown Dallas and 26 miles southeast of downtown Fort Worth. Though the current use is for a dental office, the property is zoned PD267A (commercial development), allowing for a variety of medical and dental uses. The property is owner-occupied and will be vacated at closing, providing an ideal opportunity for another dental practice or any number of medical office users to utilize the property for their practice or an investor who works with medical office tenants to take advantage of an investment opportunity.
Listing Brokers:
Tyson Grona | tyson@tysongronagroup.com | 936.444.3635
Randolph Taylor | rtaylor@creconsult.net | 630.474.6441
https://properties.expcommercial.com/1253332-sale

U.S. Apartment Rents See First Yearly Drop Since Early 2021

For the first time since the onset of the pandemic, both annual and monthly rent growth rates have turned negative.

Apartment Rent Growth Declines for the First Time Since Pandemic Onset

The apartment market, once a hotbed of growth, is seeing a downward trend in rent prices, marking a shift from its previous trajectory, as noted in the September 2023 Apartment List National Rent Report.

Rent trends: Specifically, the rent index decreased by 0.1% in August 2023. Interestingly, this decline started a month earlier than it did the previous year, bucking the typical trend of prices rising in the spring and summer and dropping in the fall and winter. Just last year, all 100 surveyed cities reported positive year-over-year rent increases.

Contrast to previous years: The current annual rent growth is at -1.2%, meaning apartments are now 1.2% cheaper than they were a year ago. This is a significant change from past years when annual rent growth was as high as 18% nationally, with some cities even witnessing growth surpassing 40%.

Causes of rent volatility: Rent fluctuations primarily stem from the balance between apartment vacancies and renter demand. A previous shortage in 2021 and 2022 caused rents to soar. However, a 22-month increase in the vacancy index, now at 6.4%, and new apartment constructions have shifted the dynamics, making property owners more competitive for tenants.

City-wise overview: More than half of the country's 100 largest cities report decreasing rents. Significant drops are seen in "zoom towns" like Arizona, Nevada, Idaho, with Oakland, California, noting an 8.7% decline. Meanwhile, Midwest and New England cities, such as Chicago and Boston, show modest recent rent growth compared to prior years.

➥ THE TAKEAWAY

Zoom out: We're witnessing a pivotal shift in the rental landscape from skyrocketing rents to potentially greater leverage for renters. The slight rent decrease in August marks the beginning of a quieter rental phase, harking back to the early pandemic times in its year-over-year growth rate. With a slump in apartment demand and a surge in construction projects, the trend suggests a continued cooling of rent growth in the coming months.

Source: U.S. Apartment Rents See First Yearly Drop Since Early 2021

https://www.creconsult.net/market-trends/u-s-apartment-rents-see-first-yearly-drop-since-early-2021/

Billions Flow to Student Housing as Rents Soar

Investors are flocking to student housing as its rent growth outpaces traditional multifamily properties, lured by its resilience during economic downturns and higher-than-average returns.

Billions Funneled into Student Housing as Rent Growth Exceeds Apartment Market

 

Investors are flocking to student housing as its rent growth outpaces traditional multifamily properties, lured by its resilience during economic downturns and higher-than-average returns.

Rising star: Major investors are pouring billions into the student housing market attracted by its higher rent growth, outperforming traditional apartments. The off-campus student housing sector saw a 7.1% rent increase over six months, with some universities noting growth above 20%. Seen as "recession-proof," investments are especially concentrated in Sun Belt states, known for their substantial rent and enrollment hikes. However, this trend has raised concerns over the capacity of campus housing.

Student housing rent growth this year has far outpaced previous years, data from Yardi Matrix shows.

Student housing vs. apartment market: While student housing rents have surged, apartment rents have begun to plateau after reaching record highs in the past. For instance, student housing rent growth this year has substantially surpassed previous years, with data indicating a marked increase in rent growth rates. In contrast, multifamily property rents rose at a more modest rate, making student housing a more appealing investment.

Major deals: BREIT's acquisition of American Campus Communities for $13B last year underscored the growing appeal of student housing in the commercial real estate market. In addition, Blackstone's ACC has initiated two major student housing projects within its $3B program. However, as student enrollments rise, many universities struggle to provide adequate housing, leading to local market imbalances. Cities such as Boston, for instance, are experiencing shortages in off-campus apartments.

Shifting tides: Investor interest in student housing is now leaning towards luxury properties near campuses. Last year saw record property sales in this sector, with over $10B invested for two straight years. However, 1H23 saw a slower investment pace due to higher rates, changing the investor landscape. Investment funds made up 52% of deals in 1H23, a jump from 12% in 2H22, while universities and public REITs reduced their participation. There's also a spike in foreign investment, especially from the Middle East and Asia.

➥ THE TAKEAWAY

Campus housing crunch: The booming student housing sector is a double-edged sword. On the one hand, it's attracting significant investment, but on the other, it's amplifying accommodation issues in university towns. With universities experiencing record enrollments, there's an urgent need to house the growing student body without overburdening local housing markets. As enrollments surge, investors are faced with the challenge of benefiting from this growth while also addressing the housing deficits in academic communities.

Source: Billions Flow to Student Housing as Rents Soar

https://www.creconsult.net/market-trends/billions-flow-to-student-housing-as-rents-soar/

1120 E Ogden Ave

New Listing | Retail-Office For Sale Naperville IL
eXp Commercial is pleased to present to market 1120 E Ogden Avenue, a highly visible 10,860 square foot retail-office property on 1.26 acres in desirable affluent Naperville, Illinois, along the I-88 E-W corridor approximately 28 miles west of Chicago. The property is currently owner-occupied and will be fully vacated shortly after closing, with the seller seeking approximately 60 days of post-closing possession. Flexible B3 zoning allows for a number of retail and office uses, ideal for an investor, owner-user, or redevelopment of the property.
Listing Broker: Randolph Taylor | rtaylor@creconsult.net

https://www.creconsult.net/retail-office-for-sale-1120-e-ogden-ave-naperville-il-60563/

The New Era of Rental Prices

For renters who've felt the sting of rapidly increasing costs, there's a sigh of relief on the horizon. The rapid inflation of rent prices, which has been a pressing concern for many in recent years, is showing signs of stabilization.

From Skyrocketing to Stabilizing: The New Era of Rental Prices

Analysis based on average monthly rent data for provided by CoStar Group. The data includes newly posted rents, not lease renewals, for 1,660 counties for June of each year from 2019 to 2023. Counties with fewer than 1,000 multi-units, according to Census Bureau data, were excluded.

Good news is on the horizon for renters: The rapid escalation in rental prices, which had previously seemed unstoppable, appears to be taking a pause.

Rental rollercoaster: Between 2020 and 2022, rents surged by a striking 15%, the most rapid increase in nearly a century. However, the fervor has calmed. Rent growth has reverted to pre-pandemic rates, seeing an annual growth of about 1 to 3 percent. Interestingly, in cities that recently witnessed surging rents like Austin and Atlanta, prices are now dropping. As Igor Popov, chief economist at Apartment List, observes, the rental market is "taking a breath.

Why the slowdown? A significant factor in this slowdown is the surge in housing construction. An impressive nearly 1 million new apartment units are currently under construction nationwide. By the end of 2023, over half of these are expected to be on the market. Concurrently, the demand for rentals is waning as the U.S. adjusts to post-pandemic life. The appetite for apartment living has decreased, with fewer individuals moving out and more staying in familial homes. This change has created a discrepancy between available apartments and interested renters, thereby stabilizing price growth.

The Sun Belt phenomenon: The Sun Belt region, which includes parts of the Southern U.S., experienced a unique scenario. Initially, during the pandemic, there was a spike in demand as individuals sought warmer climates and more affordable living conditions, moving away from urban centers like New York. This shift led to a boom in rental prices in cities like Phoenix, Dallas, and Miami. However, the rush to meet this demand has led to an oversupply, causing rents to stabilize and even decrease in some areas.

➥ THE TAKEAWAY

The new normal: While renters can find solace in stabilizing prices and even some reductions, it's crucial to note that the cost of renting remains substantially higher than pre-pandemic levels in many areas. Areas like Atlanta, despite witnessing recent rent reductions, still have renters paying substantially more than before the pandemic. The introduction of incentives like months of free rent indicates a market adjusting to new realities, but the days of pre-pandemic affordability seem to be a distant memory for now.

Source: The New Era of Rental Prices

https://www.creconsult.net/market-trends/the-new-era-of-rental-prices/

Mid-Priced Apartment Demand Soars Amid Economic Uptick

Plus: CoStar's analysis shows a continued dip in CRE sale prices in October, aligning with the ongoing trend of increased rates.

Leasing Surge in Mid-Priced Apartments with Improved Economy

In 2023, the U.S. multifamily market has seen a significant upswing in renter demand, especially for mid-priced apartments rated three stars. This shift marks a recovery from a sluggish performance in the latter half of 2022.

A surge in demand: There has been a 77% increase in occupancy over the last year, with 260,000 more units being filled than vacated. This surge is primarily in mid-priced, three-star properties, contrasting with the disappointing absorption of only 146,000 units in 2022.

Influencing the market: The market slump in 2022 was driven by a combination of high inflation, increased oil prices, and recession fears, which significantly impacted consumer confidence and demand, especially in mid- and low-priced properties. This led to renters seeking more affordable housing solutions or delaying household formation.

Improving economy: The rebound in 2023 has been fueled by improved consumer confidence, lower inflation, strong wage growth, and reduced recession fears. These factors have notably increased the demand for three-star properties by 54,000 units in the first three quarters of the year.

➥ THE TAKEAWAY

Positive outlook: The high-end segment of the market, comprising four- and five-star properties, has remained stable, thanks to the lower rent-to-income ratio of its renter households. Looking ahead, if the economy avoids a recession, multifamily demand could return to pre-pandemic levels by 2024, although supply is expected to exceed demand for the third consecutive year.

 

Source: Mid-Priced Apartment Demand Soars Amid Economic Uptick

https://www.creconsult.net/market-trends/mid-priced-apartment-demand-soars-amid-economic-uptick/